North Dakota State University
NDSU Extension Service


Survey of Weeds in North Dakota - 2000

ER-83, May 2003
R. K. Zollinger, NDSU Extension Weed Specialist


Table 131. HRS wheat and barley losses in North Dakota from various weeds in 1978 and 1979 based on individual weed competition data (from Dexter et al. 1981).
HRS wheat Barley
Weed Infestations Weed Infestations
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
1978 % pl/m2 1000 % 1000 bu % pl/m2 1000 % 1000 bu
Green foxtail 94 43.3 9,212 3.0 8,475   98 43.3 2,450 2.3 2,653
Yellow foxtail 17 18.5 1,666 1.5 756   2 18.0 50 1.1 26
Wild oat 67 9.5 6,566 8.0 17,014   63 11.3 1,575 7.1 5,537
Wild buckwheat 54 5.2 5,292 1.5 2,402   53 8.6 1,325 1.5 928
Wild mustard 12 2.8 1,176 2.0 715   13 3.2 325 1.7 259
Field bindweed 9 7.6 882 18.0 5,770   9 6.6 225 8.9 999
Canada thistle 11 3.5 1,078 17.0 6,580   15 4.6 375 15.0 3,044
Total     14.3 41,712   11.7 13,446
1979  
Green foxtail 95 74.6 9,405 5.0 13,018   99 93.5 1,717 4.7 3,895
Yellow foxtail 27 21.1 2,673 1.5 1,070   25 34.3 425 1.7 338
Wild oat 67 7.6 6,633 7.0 13,130   67 8.0 1,139 5.1 2,816
Wild buckwheat 66 4.2 6,534 1.0 1,735   86 5.0 1,462 0.8 542
Wild mustard 39 3.4 3,861 2.4 2,497   32 2.1 544 1.1 278
Field bindweed 19 5.0 1,881 9.0 4,893   10 2.8 170 3.8 309
Canada thistle 17 2.3 1,683 15.0 7,811   32 3.4 544 12.7 3,640
Total   17.0 44,154   15.1 11,818

a Acres infested was obtained by multiplying weed frequency by crop acres which was 9.8 million (m) for HRS wheat and 2.5 m for barley in 1978 and 9.9 m for HRS wheat and 1.7 m for barley.

b Percent yield loss caused by weed competition was based on weed density and competition data from the literature as follows: green and yellow foxtail (assumed similar), wild oat, wild mustard, and wild buckwheat (Nalewaja 1972), field bindweed (Gigax 1978), and Canada thistle (Hodgson 1968). Total % yield loss is based on all acres.

c Grain loss based on average North Dakota production of 29.8 bu/A for HRS wheat and 46 bu/A for barley in 1978 and 26.3 bu/A for HRS wheat and 46 bu/A for barley in 1979. Losses from weed competition in barley were only available for wild oat where loss in barley was about 25% less than in HRS wheat for wild oat plants (Bell and Nalewaja 1968). The losses in barley from all weeds were assumed at 25% less than in HRS wheat.

 
Table 132. Crop losses in North Dakota from various weeds in summer 2000 based on individual weed competition data.
HRS wheat, durum, and barley Canola
Weed Infestations Weed Infestations
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
% pl/m2 1000 % 1000 bu % pl/m2 1000 % 1000 lb
Green foxtail 57 31.5 6,327 2.5 4,551   11 28.5 138 - -
Wild oat 54 12.0 5,994 10.0 20,852   53 11.9 663 9.6 83,952
Yellow foxtail 32 27.9 3,552 2.5 3,091   - - - - -
Wild buckwheat 38 11.3 4,218 4.0 5,870   5 5.4 63 - -
Kochia 41 8.4 4,551 5.0 7,916   53 9.0 663 - -
Canada thistle 32 8.2 3,552 27.0 35,502   42 8.9 525 14.1 97,713
Pigweed species 23 8.9 2,553 - -   5 5.4 63 - -
Field bindweed 12 9.3 1,332 25.0 12,327   - - - - -
Quackgrass 12 7.9 1,332 - -   11 4.8 138 1.6 2,904
Common lambsquarters 11 5.0 1,221 - -   16 4.3 200 - -
Common ragweed 9 8.9 999 21.0 7,298   11 6.5 138 - -
Russian thistle 9 6.6 999 - -   - - - - -
Common milkweed 11 3.9 1,221 22.0 9,335   - - - - -
Perennial sowthistle 7 4.7 777 11.0 2,973   26 4.3 325 3.3 14,157
Sunflower 7 3.4 777 10.0 2,703   11 2.2 138 - -
Wild mustard 6 6.2 666 5.0 1,158   37 6.8 463 16.0 97,680
Field pennycress 4 9.7 444 - -   5 1.1 63 - -
Barnyardgrass 5 3.6 555 - -   5 4.3 63 - -
Common cocklebur 4 4.1 444 12.0 1,854   5 1.1 63 - -
Volunteer cereal - - - - -   16 8.3 200 11.3 29,832
Flixweed/Tansy mustard 2 0.6 220 - -   16 4.3 200 10.0 26,400
Total     28.1 115,430       21.4 352,638

a Acres infested was obtained by multiplying weed frequency by crop acres which was 6.4 million for HRS wheat, 2.9 m for durum wheat, 1.8 m for barley, and 1.25 m for canola in 2000 (NDAS 2002).

b Percent yield loss caused by weed competition was based on weed density and competition data from the literature:

HRS wheat, durum wheat and barley: green and yellow foxtail (assumed similar), wild oat, wild mustard, and wild buckwheat (Nalewaja 1972), kochia (Dahl 1984), Canada thistle and perennial sowthistle (perennial sowthistle assumed 50% less than Canada thistle) (Donald 1990, Hodgson 1968), field bindweed (Gigax 1978), common milkweed (Yenish et al. 1997), and common sunflower, common ragweed, common cocklebur (assumed similar) (Gillespie 1982).

Canola: wild oat, Canada thistle, quackgrass, perennial sowthistle, and volunteer cereal (Canola Grower Manual). Total % yield loss is based on all acres.

c Grain loss based on average North Dakota production of 36.5 bu/A for HRS wheat, 27 bu/A for durum wheat, 55 bu/A for barley, and 1,320 lbs/A for canola in 2000 (NDAS 2002). Losses from weed competition in barley were only available for wild oat where loss in barley was about 25% less than in HRS wheat for wild oat plants (Bell and Nalewaja 1968). The losses in barley from all weeds were assumed at 25% less than in HRS wheat.
 

Table 132 (continued).

Soybean and dry bean Sunflower
Weed Infestations Weed Infestations
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
Weed
Freq.
Weed
Density

Acresa
Yield
Lossb
Grain
Lossc
% pl/m2 1000 % 1000 bu % pl/m2 1000 % 1000 lb
Green foxtail 35 9.1 831 5 1,330   73 21.0 927 13 165,599
Wild oat 11 5.6 261 20 1,672   27 8.5 343 20 94,229
Yellow foxtail 27 10.8 641 6 1,231   32 20.5 406 13 72,591
Wild buckwheat 13 4.1 308 - -   36 7.1 457 - -
Kochia 25 7.0 594 - -   43 5.1 546 22 165,075
Canada thistle 31 4.6 736 - -   43 6.8 547 - -
Pigweed species 16 6.2 380 40 4,864   35 5.8 445 - -
Field bindweed 4 4.3 95 - -   18 5.1 229 - -
Quackgrass 10 5.4 238 0 0   12 9.7 152 - -
Common lambsquarters 13 3.6 309 28 2,766   15 2.9 191 - -
Common ragweed 17 3.0 404 26 3,359   25 8.0 318 - -
Russian thistle 2 3.2 48 - -   24 3.3 305 - -
Common milkweed 8 3.4 190 - -   3 3.0 38 - -
Biennial wormwood 11 3.6 261 20 1,672   - - - - -
Sunflower 8 5.1 190 69 4,195   - - - - -
Wild mustard 9 3.0 214 30 2,052   14 5.8 178 13 31,759
Field pennycress 3 12.9 71 - -   9 6.0 114 - -
Flixweed/Tansy mustard 4 2.2 95 - -   11 1.1 140 - -
Canola 0.5 2.2 19 22 84   8 30.8 102 31 43,276
Common cocklebur 10 5.3 238 68 5,168   11 2.8 140 - -
Volunteer cereal 14 6.6 333 22 2,341   16 10.9 203 25 69,799
Eastern black nightshade 9 5.7 214 14 958   16 6.3 203 - -
Barnyardgrass 4 3.0 95 - -   1 1.1 13 - -
Common mallow 5 2.8 119 - -   8 4.4 10 - -
Total   41.7 31,692     36.8 642,328

a Acres infested was obtained by multiplying weed frequency by crop acres which was 1.85 million for soybean, 0.525 m for dry beans, and 1.27 m for sunflower in 2000 (NDAS 2002).

b Percent yield loss caused by weed competition was based on weed density and competition data from the literature:

Soybean and dry beans (assume equal yield reduction even though dry beans are less competitive than soybean and would result in a greater % yield loss): green and yellow foxtail (assume similar), wild oat, volunteer cereal (assume similar), pigweed, common ragweed (assume similar), wild mustard, volunteer canola (assume similar), common cocklebur (Stoller et al. 1987), common lambsquarters (Crook and Renner 1990), biennial wormwood (Nelson 1992), sunflower (Auwater 1978), nightshade (Blackshaw 1991), quackgrass (Young et al. 1982).

Sunflower: green and yellow foxtail (assume similar), wild oat, volunteer cereals (assume similar), wild mustard, volunteer canola (assume similar), kochia (Blamey et al. 1997). Total % yield loss is based on all acres.

c Grain loss based on average North Dakota production of 34 bu/A for soybean, 1,450 lbs/A for dry beans, and 1,374 lbs/A for sunflower in 2000 (NDAS 2002).

Continue to next page

EB-83, May 2003


NDSU Extension Service, North Dakota State University of Agriculture and Applied Science, and U.S. Department of Agriculture cooperating. Sharon D. Anderson, Director, Fargo, North Dakota. Distributed in furtherance of the Acts of Congress of May 8 and June 30, 1914. We offer our programs and facilities to all persons regardless of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, age, Vietnam era veterans status, or sexual orientation; and are an equal opportunity employer. This publication will be made available in alternative format upon request to people with disabilities (701) 231-7881. North Dakota State University NDSU Extension Service