North Dakota State University

NDSU

North Central Research Extension Center
Brian Jenks
Weed Scientist
bjenks@ndsuext.nodak.edu

 
Denise Markle
Research Specialist
dmarkle@ndsuext.nodak.edu
Gary Willoughby
Research Specialist
gwillough@ndsuext.nodak.edu
5400 Highway 83 South
Minot, ND  58701-7662
701.857.7679
701.857.7676 (fax)

Study Name: Influence of Roundup/Insecticide tankmix on weed control in canola

Study Number: 9929

Objectives: Determine if a Roundup/Insecticide mixture will antagonize weed control

Results: The field was prepared under a conventional tillage system. The canola seed was not treated with Gaucho at my request. Now I look at it as not such a good idea. The flea beetle and weed populations were so heavy that we had to apply the herbicide/insecticide mixture at the cotyledon stage. Some plants were at the one-leaf stage. Weed control was excellent with all of the treatments. There were no visual differences in weed control. A couple weeks after application, the field was clean except for the untreated checks.

However, we should have made at least one or two more insecticide applications because of new flea beetle populations. The impact was such that the canola growth was extremely slow and allowed new flushes of weeds to come through.

We should have made a second application of Roundup to the entire plot to control the new flushes of lambsquarters and pigweed. The effect of the flea beetles and new weed flushes explain the extremely low yields. I kept expecting the canola to really start growing and shade out the weeds, but it never really did. It is clear from this study and others that unless the canola crop is actively growing very early, without competition from flea beetles, a single application at the cotyledon to 2-leaf stage will not be sufficient to keep weeds from reducing yields.

Table. Influence of Roundup/Insecticide tankmix on weed control in canola

   

June 21

Yield (lb/A)

Test Weight

   

Wioa

Fxtl

Colq

Rrpw

Wibw

Treatment

Rate

-----------% control----------

   
Roundup Ultra + AMS

1 pt + 1 %

100

100

100

100

90

706

48.3

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Warrior

1 pt + 1 % + 0.015 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

679

48

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Warrior

1 pt + 1 % + 0.03 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

854

48

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Asana XL

1 pt + 1 % + 0.025 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

719

48.1

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Asana XL

1 pt + 1 % + 0.05 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

815

48.7

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Sevin XLR Plus

1 pt + 1 % + 0.5 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

836

48.6

Roundup Ultra + AMS + Sevin XLR Plus

1 pt + 1 % + 1 lb ai

100

100

100

100

90

800

48.7

Weedy check  

0

0

0

0

0

154

 


Ag Alerts |  Agronomic Research |  Canola Rotation Study |  Foundation Seed Information |  Fungicide Research |  Livestock Notes
Personnel |  Pest Notes |  Upcoming Events |  Variety Trial Data (NCREC) |  Weather Data (NCREC) |  Weed Control Research


All Research Extension Centers
                   
   

 
   

Last Updated: Thursday, May 27, 2004 02:49:18 PM
Published by North Dakota State University