North Dakota State University

NDSU

North Central Research Extension Center Jan Knodel
Crop Protection Specialist
jknodel@ndsuext.nodak.edu
5400 Highway 83 South
Minot, ND  58701-7662
701.857.7679
701.857.7676 (fax)

   
2002 Canola Insect Pest Trapping Network

Janet J. Knodel, Crop Protection Specialist, North Central Research and Extension Center, Minot
Lorilie M. Atkinson, IPM Scout, North Central Research and Extension Center, Minot

Purpose and Objective: 

To monitor for three insect pests of canola using pheromone traps and sticky traps in the major canola growing areas of North Dakota: Bertha armyworm (Mamestra configurata), Diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella), and crucifer flea beetle (Phyllotreta cruciferae). Trap data provided  growers, Ag consultants, Ag field researchers, and extension agents/specialists with an  "early" warning system of when the pest were active and how many. 

Summary of Results 

Bertha Armyworm: 
The peak flight for Bertha armyworms (BA) occurred during late June to early July. Highest trap catches were located at trap sites in Bottineau  County (Table 1). East Mohall and Westhope had a total of 927 and 871  moths per season, respectively. Other areas had cumulative trap catches  below 300 and were at low risk of infestation. No bertha armyworm was  captured at Mercer, Hazen County. The cumulative moth capture during  2002 was 6,002 with an average of 188 moths per trap day from 32 trap sites including 13 counties in North Dakota and 2 counties in Minnesota. In Table 2, the cumulative trap capture and the average number of moth per trap day are listed from 1998 through 2002. 

Based on the Canadian trapping guidelines,
  • 3% (or one trap site) was in the "moderate" risk level or fields should be scouted regularly for larvae and damage;
  • 22% (or 7 trap sites) were in the "uncertain" risk level or unlikely that fields will be infested with larvae; and
  • 75% (or 24 trap sites) were in the "low" risk of larval infestation. 

Overall, the total number of bertha armyworm captured was similar to numbers in 2001 with the  peak flight occurring between late June and mid-July. However, the average moth per trap day  was twice as high as 2001 (Table 2). Since the canola crop was also planted later in 2002, the  larvae primarily fed on the leaves and not the pods causing minimal impact to canola yields.  However, there was limited spraying in isolated "hot" spots. The presence of natural controls like a nuclear polyhedrosis virus and fungi were common in fields as well. Bertha armyworm populations will need to be monitored until local populations decrease in the areas with high pheromone trap catches.

 

Table 1. Pheromone Trap Catches for Bertha Armyworm and Diamondback Moth from 1998 through 2002.

 

Year

Bertha Armyworm

Diamondback Moth

Total # of Moths per trap season

Average moth per trap day

Total # of Moths per trap season

Average moth per trap day

1998

2,739

94

11,348

195

1999

1,939

39

5,900

112

2000

1,132

21

6,515

123

2001

5,003

87

17,901

311

2002

6,002

188

8,174

195


Diamondback Moths:

Diamondback moth migrated into North Dakota in mid to late May. The first  flight of Diamondback moths (DBM) was so low that is was difficult to detect.  The second flight occurred late in mid to late July. The total number of DBMs  captured was 8,174 moths with an average of 195 moths per trap day from 32 trap  sites including 13 counties in North Dakota and 2 counties in Minnesota (Table 3).  These numbers represent a two-fold decrease over last year (Table 2). Field scouting is usually  necessary when more than 100 DBMs are captured per trap week for several weeks prior to  bloom to early bud development. In 2002, diamondback moth arrived in low numbers late and  canola fields did not suffered any yield losses. Sites with the highest trap count of >500 moths  per trap season included: Ward County, Slope County, Stark County in North Dakota and  Kittson County in Minnesota. No diamondback moths were captured at Hazen in Mercer County. 

Crucifer Flea Beetles:

During 2002, the crucifer flea beetle (FB) activity started late, close to late-May, which was similar to 2001. A total of 35,597 FBs were captured on sticky yellow traps from 17 different trap sites with an average trap catch of 818 beetles per trap day (Table 4). The highest average trap catch  was 187 beetles per trap day in Minot, 164 beetles per trap day in Souris, and 102 beetles per trap day in Langdon. There were two major peaks with the major activity in late May, and again in late June. Minot had the highest cumulative trap catch with 18,504 total FBs, then Souris with 7,034  total FBs, Langdon with 3,993 total FBs. The FB trap catches were lower at other sites partly  because the monitoring effort was not as continuous throughout the field season, and traps may  have been placed in commercial insecticide seed-treated canola fields. Traps were also monitored longer (end of July) at the research extension centers. Flea beetle pressure was generally lower from regions where canola has been grown for only a few years, such as Southwest. The duration of the feeding period was typical – approximately 1 to 1.5 months long. The majority of the canola crop was planted during mid to late May in the North Dakota, which provided opportune time for the emerging flea beetles to infest. The weather conditions in 2002 were conducive to early flea beetle feeding throughout North Dakota. As a result, most canola fields were severely damaged from FBs. Many fields had to be rescued with one or more applications of a foliar insecticide regardless of whether the seed was treated with an insecticide or not.

Canola Insect Trapping Network Web Site: 

Data for the Canola Insect Trapping Network was updated weekly on the NC Research Extension Center’s webpage under "Pest Notes" during the 2002 field season:

                                                http://www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/minot/pest/pn.htm 

Please see the website for more information from the different field sites. 

Acknowledgments: Authors would like to thank the numerous trap cooperators, which included County Extension  Agents, Area Extension Specialists, Crop Consultants in North Dakota and Minnesota for making this a successful network.

 

Table 2.  2002 Bertha armyworm summary – sorted by trap site in descending order of total number for moths per trap season.

County

Site

Total # Moths

Total Trap Days

Moth/ Trapping Day

Moth/ Trapping Week

Bottineau

Mohall, East

927

36

25.75

180.00

Bottineau

Westhope Bentinck

871

22

39.59

277.39

Bottineau

Gardena

678

28

24.21

169.50

Bottineau

Westhope Sergius

555

36

15.42

107.80

Bottineau

Newburg

545

22

24.77

173.57

Bottineau

Westhope Wayne 25

531

22

24.14

169.11

Bottineau

Bottineau

408

28

14.57

102.00

Bottineau

Souris

394

22

17.91

125.48

Ward

Deering

253

35

7.23

50.60

Mountrail

Makoti

118

28

4.21

29.50

Hettinger

New England 1

93

43

2.16

15.15

Hettinger

Mott

92

36

2.56

17.80

Ward

NCREC, Minot

91

43

2.12

14.82

Slope

Bowman

73

43

1.70

11.89

Hettinger

New England 2

70

43

1.63

11.40

Divide

Crosby

49

36

1.36

9.51

Foster

Carrington REC

39

28

1.39

9.75

Mountrail

Belden

37

21

1.76

12.33

Cavalier

Langdon REC

32

29

1.10

7.73

Kittson

Kennedy, MN

32

36

0.89

6.23

Dunn

New Hrder

28

43

0.65

4.56

Mountrail

Ross

25

21

1.19

8.33

Mountrail

Powers Lake

20

21

0.95

6.67

Renville

Mohall, West

18

29

0.62

4.35

Pennington

Thief River Falls, MN

8

29

0.28

1.93

Dunn

Halliday

7

43

0.16

1.14

Stark

Dickinson

6

43

0.14

0.98

Williams

Williston

2

36

0.06

0.39

Mercer

Hazen 1

0

29

0.00

0.00

Mercer

Hazen 2

0

29

0.00

0.00

Bertha Armyworm Summary

Numbers

Total number of Moths

6,002

Average Trap Day

32

Average Moth per Trap Day

187.56

 

Table 3.  2002 DIAMONDBACK MOTH summary–sorted by trap site in descending order for total number of moths per trap season.

County

Site

Total # Moths

Total Trap Days

Moth/
Trapping 
Day

Moth/
Trapping 
Week

Ward

NCREC, Minot

662

50

13.24

92.68

Kittson

Kennedy, MN

616

43

14.33

100.28

Slope

Bowman

602

50

12.04

84.28

Stark

Dickinson

552

50

11.04

77.28

Bottineau

Gardena

488

43

11.35

79.44

Bottineau

Newburg

473

43

11.00

77.00

Dunn

New Hrder

457

50

9.14

63.98

Mountrail

Makoti

451

28

16.11

112.75

Stark

Belfield

407

50

8.14

56.98

Hettinger

New England 2

380

50

10.56

73.89

Bottineau

Westhope Wayne 25

357

43

8.30

58.12

Dunn

Halliday

356

50

7.12

49.84

Hettinger

New England 1

324

50

7.53

52.74

Bottineau

Westhope Sergius

289

43

6.72

47.05

Bottineau

Souris

285

43

6.63

46.40

Renville

Mohall, West

265

35

7.57

53.00

Pennington

Thief River Falls, MN

242

36

6.72

47.06

Bottineau

Bottineau

183

43

4.26

29.79

Bottineau

Westhope Bentinck

170

43

3.95

27.67

Divide

Crosby

142

43

2.84

19.88

Bottineau

Mohall, East

112

43

2.60

18.23

Mountrail

Ross

85

15

5.67

39.67

Mountrail

Powers Lake

80

15

5.33

37.33

Ward

Deering

72

43

1.67

11.72

Mountrail

Belden

70

15

4.67

32.67

Hettinger

Mott

41

50

0.82

5.74

Cavalier

Langdon

12

43

0.28

1.95

Foster

Carrington

1

43

0.02

0.16

Mountrail

New Town

0

50

0.00

0.00

Mercer

Hazen 1

0

50

0.00

0.00

Mercer

Hazen 2

0

50

0.00

0.00

Williams

Williston

0

36

0.00

0.00

Diamondback Moth summary

Numbers

Total numbers of Moths

8,174

Average Trap Day

42

Average Moth per Trap Day

195.35

 

Table 4.  2002 FLEA BEETLE SUMMARY–sorted by trap site in descending order for total number of beetles per trap season.

County

Site

Total # Beetles

Total Trap Days

Beetles/ Trapping 
Day

Beetles/ 
Trapping 
Week

Ward

NCREC, Minot

18504

99

186.91

1308.36

Bottineau

Souris

7034

43

163.58

1145.07

Cavalier

Langdon REC

3993

39

102.38

716.69

Stark

Dickinson

1667

30

55.57

388.97

Mercer

Hazen 1

1315

67

19.63

137.39

Foster

Carrington REC

1101

40

27.53

192.68

Renville

Mohall

713

43

16.58

116.07

Mercer

Hazen 2

638

67

9.52

66.66

Ward

Deering

344

32

10.75

75.25

Dunn

Halliday

80

16

5.00

34.93

Dunn

New Hrdec

76

16

4.75

33.25

Stark

Belfield

44

30

1.47

10.27

Slope

Bowman

34

30

1.13

7.90

Divide

Crosby

24

69

0.35

2.43

Hettinger

New England 2

15

37

0.41

2.84

Mountrail

New Town

8

45

0.18

1.24

Hettinger

New England 1

7

37

0.19

1.32

Flea Beetle Summary

Numbers

Total number of Beetles

35,597

Average Trap Day

44

Average Beetle per Trap Day

817.77

 

Other Pest Links
 

NDSU Department of Entomology

NDSU Department of Plant Pathology

IPM-Integrated Pest Management

NDSU Publications

NDSU Agriculture

| To NCREC |
 

News Publications Academics Research Extension Calendar Weather Directory for Employees

 
North Dakota State University
NDSU Agriculture
VP and Dean of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Natural Resources
NDSU Extension Service
College of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Natural Resources
State Board of Agricultural Research and Education
North Central Research Extension Center
5400 Highway 83 South
Minot, ND 58701--7662
Tel. 701.857.7677
Fax. 701.857.7676
http://www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/minot

Last Updated: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 10:26:36 AM
Published by North Dakota State University