North Dakota State University

NDSU

North Central Research Extension Center Jan Knodel
Crop Protection Specialist
jknodel@ndsuext.nodak.edu
5400 Highway 83 South
Minot, ND  58701-7662
701.857.7679
701.857.7676 (fax)

   

Insecticide Efficacy against Grasshopper Nymphs on Sunflower, 2004

 

Janet J. Knodel, Area Extension Specialist – Crop Protection

Lorilie Atkinson, Research Specialist

North Central Research and Extension Center

 

Twostriped grasshopper: Melanoplus bivittatus (Say)

Migratory grasshopper: Melanoplus sanguinipes (Fabricius)

 

Registered and experimental insecticides were evaluated for their efficacy at controlling nymph stage grasshoppers and protecting sunflowers. A field in north central North Dakota near Souris, ND had pretreatment counts of >2 nymphs (1-4 instars) grasshoppers/yd2 with the majority being twostriped grasshoppers.  Plots were 10 ft wide by 30 ft long. A RCB experimental design with three replicates was used. Insecticides were applied at V2 crop stage on 19 June using a handheld CO2 boom sprayer at 40 psi, 10 gpa and fitted with XR 8001VS nozzles. Ten plants were assessed per plot for the percent defoliation at 3, 7, 14, 21, and 28 Days After Treatment (DAT). Variables were subjected to ANOVA and means compared using Fisher’s PLSD at the 5% significance level. 

 

At 3 DAT, there were no significant differences among treatments; probably due to the generally low grasshopper populations. Most of the insecticide treatments had significantly lower percent defoliation than the untreated check at 7 and 14 DAT; except for Furadan at 7 and 14 DAT, and Dimilin (1 and 2 fl oz/acre) at 7 DAT and Dimilin (1 fl oz/a) at 14 DAT. At 21 and 28 DAT, the defoliation increased slightly as grasshoppers continued to move into plots to feed and as insecticide residue was diminished. As a result, none of the insecticide treatments were significantly different from the untreated check at 21 and 28 DAT indicating reduced control and residual. Results indicate that most of the insecticides tested were able to reduce grasshopper numbers and protect sunflowers up to14 DAT.

 

 

% Defoliation

Treatment/

Rate

3 DAT

7 DAT

14 DAT

21 DAT

28 DAT

formulation

fl oz/acre

V2

V4

V8

V12

V16

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Untreated check

 

8.0 a

7.9 a

6.8 a

8.2 a

8.9 ab

Furadan 4 EC

16

3.3 a

3.9 ab

7.5 a

8.7 a

10.0 ab

Mustang Max 0.8 EC

2.8

5.0 a

2.5 b

3.3 b

5.4 a

11.5 a

Mustang Max 0.8 EC

4

5.6 a

1.8 b

3.7 b

6.0 a

10.1 ab

Baythroid 2 EC

2.8

5.2 a

2.0 b

3.0 b

6.6 a

9.3 ab

Asana XL 0.66 EC

9.6

4.5 a

1.3 b

1.4 b

5.2 a

9.6 ab

Warrior T 1 EC

3.84

4.7 a

1.5 b

3.1 b

6.8 a

9.5 ab

Danitol 2.4 EC

10⅔

3.5 a

1.9 b

2.4 b

6.3 a

9.8 ab

Dimilin 2 L

1

5.8 a

4.1 ab

7.9 a

5.7 a

7.2 b

     + Crop oil

16

 

 

 

 

 

Dimilin 2 L

2

6.0 a

4.1 ab

3.9 b

5.5 a

7.5 b

     + Crop oil

16

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Means within a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (ANOVA, Fisher’s PLSD, P<0.05).

 

Part II.  Materials Tested for Arthropod Management

 

Insecticide Efficacy against Grasshopper Nymphs on Sunflower,

Trade name

Formulation

Composition

Chemical name

Common name

Source

Asana XL

EC

0.66 lb AI/gal

esfenvalerate

asana XL

Dupont

Baythroid

EC

2 lb AI/gal

cyfluthrin

baythroid

Bayer Crop Science

Danitol

EC

2.4 lb AI/gal

fenpropathrin

danitol

Valent U.S.A. Corporation

Dimilin

L

2 lb AI/gal

diflubenzuron

dimilin

Crompton Uniroyal Chemical

Furadan

F

4 lb AI/gal

carbofuran

furadan

FMC Corp

Mustang Max 

EC

0.8 lb AI/gal

zeta-cypermethrin

cypermethrin

FMC Corp.

Warrior T 

EC

1 lb AI/gal

lambda-cyhalothrin

warrior

Syngenta Crop Protection

Prime oil

-

-

petroleum distillates

crop oil concentrate

Agrisolutions

 


Other Pest Links
 

NDSU Department of Entomology

NDSU Department of Plant Pathology

IPM-Integrated Pest Management

NDSU Publications

NDSU Agriculture

| To NCREC |
 

News Publications Academics Research Extension Calendar Weather Directory for Employees

 
North Dakota State University
NDSU Agriculture
VP and Dean of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Natural Resources
NDSU Extension Service
College of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Natural Resources
State Board of Agricultural Research and Education
North Central Research Extension Center
5400 Highway 83 South
Minot, ND 58701--7662
Tel. 701.857.7677
Fax. 701.857.7676
http://www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/minot

Last Updated: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 10:26:36 AM
Published by North Dakota State University