Home

Invasive
Weed List

Musk thistle
Carduus nutans L.

Vegetative Stage
Flowers
Growth Habits

Herbicide
Control

Musk Thistle Control in Pasture & Range


Musk thistle grows 6 to 8 feet tall and is often found in dry pastures.

 

Musk thistle flower head is characterized by large brown bracts that resemble a pine cone and the tendency to nod or lean because of the large size of the flower.

Top


T
wo subspecies of musk thistle which differ in the size of the flower head and in foliage texture and pubescence are known in North Dakota.

 

Musk thistle leaves are dark green, generally with little or no pubescence and deeply lobed with small but sharp spines. The subspecies macrocephalus does have pubescent leaves.

 

The achenes are 0.15 to 0.2 inches long, glossy, light brown with stripes and a light apical rim.

 

Stems of musk thistle have wings that do not extend completely up and down the stem which is smooth elsewhere. The heads often are 2 to 3 inches in diameter.

 

Musk thistle rosette which often grows 2 feet or more in diameter.

Top

PASTURE, RANGELAND, AND NONCROPLAND

Biennials. Fall is the preferred time for applying herbicides for biennial thistle control. Fall applications allow for more time to apply herbicides than in the spring and correspond to the most effective time for thistle control. Seedlings that emerge in summer after tillage or previous herbicide applications will not bolt but remain in the rosette stage. Biennial thistles are most susceptible to herbicides in the rosette form.

Herbicides should be applied as late as possible in the fall but prior to a killing frost to allow for maximum seedling emergence and rosette size. Seedlings that emerge after spraying will remain vegetative until the following spring and can be treated then. Long-term eradication of biennial thistles is difficult because of the large number of seeds each plant can produce.

Biennial thistles can be effectively controlled with Stinger (clopyralid), Tordon (picloram), or dicamba (Table 1). Stinger and Tordon are the most effective of these herbicides and may be applied in the spring or fall. Tordon and clopyralid (Curtail) are often mixed with 2,4-D for broad spectrum weed control. Weedmaster (dicamba plus 2,4-D) is an effective treatment and is best applied when the thistles are in the rosette growth stage. Redeem (triclopyr plus clopyralid) is labeled for thistle control in non-cropland and CRP. Escort (metsulfuron) will control biennial thistles in the spring and will eliminate seed production when applied in the bolting to bud growth stages.

Perennials. Curtail (clopyralid plus 2,4-D), Tordon (picloram), Tordon plus 2,4-D amine, dicamba, Redeem (triclopyr plus clopyralid), or 2,4-D will suppress or control perennial thistles (Table 1). Control is greatest when applied to thistle at the early-bud growth stage (early summer) or in the fall to plants in the rosette form. These herbicides applied at low rates may be the most cost-effective method for controlling dense infestations that require broadcast application. Annual retreatment will be necessary for several years to obtain long-term control.

2,4-D is used for suppression only and is most effective when applied in the spring to thistles in the vegetative growth stage (Table 1). Tordon at 1 to 2 quarts per acre (0.5 to 1 pound per acre), dicamba at 3 to 4 quarts per acre (3 to 4 pounds per acre), Stinger (clopyralid) at 1.3 pints per acre (0.5 pound per acre), or Curtail at 3 quarts per acre (0.28 plus 1.5 pounds per acre) will provide near complete control for several years, but are expensive treatments. Redeem should be applied at 2.5 to 4 pints per acre (0.7 plus 0.25 to 1.1 plus 0.4 pounds per acre) Redeem herbicide contains 0.75 pounds per gallon of clopyralid and may be a more cost effective treatment than Curtail which contains 0.4 pounds per gallon clopyralid.

GRAZING RESTRICTIONS VARY WITH HERBICIDE AND APPLICATION RATE SO READ THE LABEL CAREFULLY BEFORE USING.

For perennial thistle control in non-cropland, in addition to herbicides listed above, glyphosate may be applied in the summer or fall when thistle is at or beyond the bud stage of growth (Table 1). Perennial thistle control is usually greater when glyphosate is applied in fall rather than spring.

Top

Table 1. Herbicides for Musk thistle control in pasture, rangeland, and non-crop.

                       Perennial        Product/A
                       Product/A      (lb ai/A)                               a
                       (lb ai/A)         Biennial               Comments

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tordon              1 to 4 pints             0.5 to 2 pints            Restricted use.
(picloram)          (0.25 to 1)             (0.125 to 0.5)           Use high rate for patch treatments.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dicamba            1 to 8 pints            1 to 2 pints               Use surfactant.
                         (0.5 to 4)              (0.5 to 1)                  Use high rate for patch treatment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stinger              0.67 to 1.3 pints     0.33 to 1.3 pints        Expensive but very effective.
(clopyralid)       (0.25 to 0.5)           (0.125 to 0.5)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Curtail               6 pints                  4 to 6 pints               Cost-effective for large infestations.
(clopyralid         (0.3 + 1.5)            (1 to 1.5)                   Labeled for CRP.
+ 2,4-D)           
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Redeem            2.5 to 4 pints          1.5 to 2 pints           Very cost-effective, non-restricted use.
(triclopyr +       (0.7 to 1.1 +           (0.4 to 0.6 +             Labeled for CRP.
clopyralid)         0.25 to 0.4)            0.15 to 0.2)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dicamba +        1.5 to 4 pints +       1 to 4 pints +           Use surfactant. A commercial premix is available
2, 4-D               1 quart of a            1 quart of a             as Weedmaster.
                        4 lb/gal conc.         4 lb/gal conc.
                       
(0.75 to 2 + 1)       (0.5 to 2 + 1)   
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tordon             0.5 to 2 pints +      0.5 to 1 pint             Restricted use.
(picloram) +      1 quart of a           (0.125 + 1)
2,4-D                4 lb/gal conc. 
                        (0.125 to 0.5 + 1)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Distinct             6 oz WDG             6 oz WDG             Canada thistle suppression only.
(dicamba +        (3 + 1.2 oz)           (3 + 1.2 oz)            Non-crop use only.
diflufenzopyr)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2,4-D              1.5 to 2 quart of a     1.5 to 2 quart of a     Suppression of perennials only.
                       4 lb/gal conc.            4 lb/gal conc.
                       (1.5 to 2 lb/A)          (1.5 to 2 lb/A)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Escort               1.5 to 2 oz DF         0.5 to 2 oz DF         Use surfactant. Suppression of musk and
(metsulfuron)     (0.9 to 1.2)             (0.3 to 1.2)              Canada thistle only. Tank-mix with an auxin
                                                                                     
herbicide to improve control.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Glyphosate        2 to 6 pints of a        1 qt                        Non-cropland use. Many trade names
                       
3 lb/gal conc. or       (0.75)                      so check label for use rate and
                              1.5 to 4.5 pints of                                            surfactant needed.
                              a 4 lb/gal conc.
                        (0.75 to 2.25)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
aConsult the specific label for use and grazing restriction,
surfactant requirements, and application rate specific to thistle species.

Top