North Dakota State University * Dickinson Research Extension Center
1133 State Avenue, Dickinson, ND 58601 Voice: (701) 483-2348 FAX: (701)
483-2005
FIELD EVALUATION OF WOODY PLANT MATERIALS AT DICKINSON BRANCH EXPERIMENT STATION, DICKINSON, NORTH DAKOTA
Mike Knudson, Forester, NRCS Plant Materials Center
Introduction:
There is a need to evaluate the performance of shrub and tree species/cultivars for
windbreaks, wildlife, and recreational plantings under diverse soil and climatic
conditions. To meet this need, field evaluation planting sites representative of the major
land resource areas were located in North Dakota, South Dakota, and Minnesota, the three
states served by the Plant Materials Center (PMC). These sites provide planting locations
under long-term land tenure, for assemblies of trees and shrubs to be evaluated under
uniform culture and management. New material can be added on an annual basis. Comparisons
are then made with previously released cultivars and area of adaptation determined.
Objective:
The objective is to assemble and evaluate woody plant materials for conservation use.
Superior cultivars will be selected and released for increase by commercial nurseries.
Cooperators:
The Natural Resources Conservation Service, Plant Materials Center, Bismarck, North
Dakota, in cooperation with the North Dakota State University, Dickinson Branch Experiment
Station, Dickinson, North Dakota.
Location: This project is located one mile west of Dickinson, North Dakota, on the NDSU Dickinson Branch Experiment Station. Legal description: NE1/4 sec. 5, T. 139 N., R. 96 W., Stark County, North Dakota.
Major Land Resource Area:
The site is located in Major Land Resource Area 054, Rolling Soft Shale Plain. This
moderately dissected rolling plain is underlain by calcareous shales and sandstones.
Strongly dissected areas of sharp local relief or badland topography border major streams
and valleys in some areas. Elevation is 1,800 to 3,100 feet. Sixty percent of the area is
rangeland.
Soils:
The soil type is a Parshall fine sandy loam. The Parshall series consists of deep,
well-drained soils formed in fine sandy loam alluvium on terraces and outwash plains and
in upland swales. The surface layer and subsoil is dark grayish-brown fine sandy loam. The
underlying material is dark grayish-brown fine sandy loam and loamy fine sand.
Permeability is moderately rapid. The available water capacity is moderate. Organic matter
is high and fertility is medium.
This soil is in North Dakota windbreak suitability group 5. Included in this group are nearly level to hilly soils of the Flaxton, Lihen, Livonia, Parshall, and Vebar series among others. These are well-drained, loamy and sandy soils. They are suited to windbreak and other plantings, but selection of species is limited. Erosion hazard is serious. The moderate available water capacity is the main limitation.
Climate:
For MLRA 054 the average annual precipitation is 13 to 19 inches; increasing from west to
east for this semiarid area. Rainfall is highest from late spring to midsummer and very
low during the rest of the year. Winter precipitation is snow. Average annual temperature
is 40 to 45 degrees F. Average freeze-free period is 110 to 135 days. The plant hardiness
zone is 4a, with an average annual minimum temperature of -30 to -20 degrees F.
Methods and Materials
Assembly:
Refer to the plot map for woody species currently planted at the site.
Planting Plan:
Plots are not randomized or replicated but systematically arranged for ease of evaluation
and demonstration purposes. The planting site is approximately 500 feet long and 200 feet
wide. The area is divided into five blocks. Each block consists of single row,
non-replicated plots. Each plot contains a minimum of 5 plants. Row length is 100 feet and
spacing between rows is 20 feet. Block 1A contains primarily poplar accessions. Block 1B
contains conifers. Block 2 contains shrubs and small trees. Block 3 contains medium sized
trees. Block 4 contains tall trees. Refer to the plot map. All trees are spaced ten feet
within row and shrubs are spaced five feet within row. All rows run from west to east.
Like species and standards of comparison are established in adjacent plots whenever
possible.
Plot Preparation:
A clean, firm planting site is prepared annually by disking and harrowing.
Planting Method:
All trees and shrubs were hand planted using approved forestry methods.
Fertilization:
No fertilizer has been applied to planting area.
Weed Control:
No herbicide has been applied to any plot during year of establishment or in succeeding
years. Weeds were controlled by clean cultivating between rows, within row, and in fallow
areas. Four to six tillage operations were performed each year in the months of May
through August. A minimum of hand hoeing was done to control weeds in rows. Recently, a
Weed Badger has been used around the trees.
Pest Control:
Previous years: No animal repellent or insecticide was applied in 1978. In the fall 1979,
an animal repellent, Arasan 50, was sprayed on fruit trees to discourage rodent damage.
1980 - 1981: On November 6, 1980, and October 29, 1981, Arasan 50 was applied to the trunks and lower limbs of fruit trees to deter rodents from damaging bark and cambium. Conifers also received this spray treatment to discourage animal browse. No insecticides were applied.
1982 - 1998: No animal repellents or insecticides have been applied.
Irrigation:
Each year, newly planted materials were watered with a portable tank. No water was added
following year of establishment. During the drought years of 1988-1991 the trees were
watered in the summer.
Crop Residue Management:
During 1990 and 1991 a cover crop was maintained to prevent soil erosion.
Silvicultural Practices:
Extensive pruning was done in 1979-1980 to reshape trees damaged by animals. Dead trees
and broken branches were cut and removed each year for sanitation. In 1988, some Russian
olive accessions were treated with Tordon, using a hypo-hatchet, with unsuccessful
results. In 1989, those treated accessions were cut down, but resprouted. These trees were
removed by tractor in 1993.
Evaluations and Measurements:
Records of planting date, survival, vigor, canopy width, height, cold hardiness, animal
damage, insect damage, disease symptoms, and unusual or outstanding features have been
maintained since 1978. Data does not appear in this report but is available upon request
from the PMC.
Results
Plant Performance:
Currently, 84 accessions of 51 species are under evaluation. This site is maintained by
the Dickinson Experiment Station. Very little weed competition has occurred within row. A
favorable microclimate is provided by surrounding shelterbelts. This undoubtedly reduces
exposure to extreme temperatures and winds and desiccation and winter injury. Annual
rainfall amounts are similar to Bismarck. The drought years of 1988 and 1989 have severely
hampered establishment and performance. With the extended dry weather in 1990 and 1991,
the original windbreak of spruce planted on the border died. A number of planted
accessions have also died. Generally, the precipitation since that time has been slightly
above normal. Many of the trees, especially the poplars have put on considerable growth.
The larches have also performed well.
PLOT MAP
Block 1A |
Block 1B |
Block 2 |
||||
| Row 1 | 14272 poplar |
14271 poplar |
ND-1729 Siberian larch |
ND-313 red tatarian honeysuckle |
ND-1730 red tatarian honeysuckle |
|
Row 2 |
14274 poplar |
Manitou poplar |
SL-383-T Siberian larch |
ND-628 silverberry |
Bighorn aromatic sumac |
|
Row 3 |
14392 Walker poplar |
Canam Walker poplar |
ND-1765 Siberian larch |
ND-26, 452 honeysuckle |
ND-170 cotoneaster |
|
Row 4 |
ND-3796 white poplar |
Raverdeau poplar |
ND-1763 Ponderosa pine |
ND-1565 bristlecone pine |
Bighorn skunkbush sumac |
Regal Russian almond |
Row 5 |
9069170 English oak |
9069090 quaking aspen |
9057413 Ponderosa pine |
9063151 Dahurian larch |
ND-11 amur honeysuckle |
Centennial cotoneaster |
Row 6 |
9063146 Walker poplar |
Assiniboine poplar |
9069172 Scotch pine |
11737 Siberian elm |
9069128 honeysuckle |
|
Row 7 |
9063141 eastern cottonwood |
9076723 Siberian elm |
408 Siberian elm |
ND-3803 white poplar |
9076737 black cherry |
|
Row 8 |
9016318 Siberian elm |
9076725 smoothleaf elm |
9076722 European white birch |
9069171 Siberian elm |
9063142 Japanese cherry |
|
Row 9 |
9069164 Scotch pine |
9069168 Siberian larch |
9063148 corktree |
ND-21 nannyberry |
Homestead Arnold hawthorn |
|
Row 10 |
9069081 littleleaf linden |
9063126 Japanese elm |
SD-131 mayday |
9057438 salt tree |
||
|
Block 1A |
Block 1B |
Block 2 |
|||
PLOT MAP (continued)
Block 3 |
Block 4 |
|||||
| Midwest Manchurian crabapple |
Red
Splendor crabapple |
SD-156 green ash |
ND-1734 green ash |
Row 1 |
||
| ND-1731 Siberian crabapple |
McDermand Ussurian pear |
Cardan green ash |
ND-1759 green ash |
Row 2 |
||
| Freedom honeysuckle |
9063143 red tatarian honeysuckle |
9008041 false indigo |
Arnolds Red honeysuckle |
ND-647 black ash |
ND-1432 Ohio buckeye |
Row 3 |
| Konza aromatic sumac |
Scarlet Mongolian cherry |
Legacy late lilac |
ND-1879 honeylocust |
Row 4 |
||
| Sakakawea silver buffaloberry |
Magenta crabapple |
9063116 black ash |
Row 5 |
|||
| 9076726 tatarian maple |
ND-1336 chokecherry |
9063115 green ash |
9076724 Russian olive |
Row 6 |
||
| ND-989 Japanese elm |
9069166 Russian olive |
Row 7 |
||||
| ND-1134 plum |
ND-629 amur maple |
Oahe hackberry |
Row 8 |
|||
| ND-1873 amur maple |
ND-686 Pekin lilac |
SD-75 hackberry |
Row 9 |
|||
| 9069129 amur chokecherry |
3890 Russian olive |
9057410 hackberry |
Row 10 |
|||
Block 3 |
Block 4 |
|||||