1998 Dry Bean Grower Survey of Pest Problems and Pesticide Use in Minnesota and North Dakota 

ER 58
1998

Weed Problems

Nightshade was the worst weed problem for 29% of Northarvest respondents on 36% of the acres reported. This percentage is up from 14% of respondents and 18% of acres in 1997 when nightshade also was the worst weed problem. In 1996 nightshade was the worst weed for 12% of respondents on 12% of their acres; it was the second worst weed behind wild mustard (Table 13). The nightshade problem has increased dramatically in recent years due to wetter weather, high seed production and dissemination, multiple flushes, and lack of control in row crops.

Redroot pigweed was the worst weed for 10% of Northarvest respondents, representing 10% of the acres reported. Canada thistle was the worst weed for 10% of respondents on 9% of the acres reported, and foxtail was the worst weed for 8% of respondents on 8% of their acres. Ragweed was the worst weed for 9% of respondents on 6% of the acres reported, followed by kochia for 5% of respondents on 6% of their acres, cocklebur for 6% of respondents on 6% of their acres, wild mustard for 5% of respondents on 5% of their acres and lambsquarters for 8% of respondents on 5% of their acres (Table 13). Wild mustard was the worst weed in 1996, the fifth worst weed in 1997 and the eighth worst weed in 1998, indicating a shift in weed problems since 1996.

In Minnesota, nightshade was the worst weed for 30% of survey respondents on 37% of the Minnesota acres reported. This contrasts to 1997 when it was the third worst weed in Minnesota, reported as the worst on 14% of respondents' acres. Nightshade was the worst weed on nearly three times as many acres in 1998 as in 1997. Redroot pigweed was the worst weed for 14% of respondents on 18% of the acres reported. This is a decrease from 1997 when redroot pigweed was the worst weed for 26% of respondents on 28% of their acres. Ragweed was the worst weed for 18% of respondents on 17% of their acres, followed by lambsquarters which was the worst weed for 19% of respondents on 16% of their acres and foxtail which was the worst weed for 7% of respondents on 6% of their acres (Table 13).

In North Dakota, nightshade was the worst weed for 29% of respondents on 35% of the North Dakota acres reported, nearly double 1997 when it was the worst weed for 14% of respondents' on 19% of their acres. Canada thistle was the worst weed for 14% of respondents on 13% of acres reported, which is similar to 1997 and 1996. Foxtail, cocklebur and redroot pigweed were each the worst weed for 8% of respondents on 8%, 8% and 7% of respondents' acres, respectively. Kochia and wild mustard each was the worst weed for 6% of respondents on 7% of their acres (Table 13). Foxtail and wild mustard each was a less common problem in 1998 than in 1997. Cocklebur was about the same both years.

Table 13: Worst weed problem in 1998 in Minnesota and North Dakota

 

Worst Weed Problema

Respondents

Acres Reported b

Number

%

Number

%

Minnesota

Nightshade

17

29.8

9,114

36.6

Redroot Pigweed

8

14.0

4,429

17.8

Ragweed

10

17.5

4,230

17.0

Lambsquarters

11

19.3

3,995

16.0

Foxtail

4

7.0

1,515

6.1

Kochia

1

1.8

600

2.4

Wild Mustard

2

3.5

461

1.9

North Dakota

Nightshade

34

28.6

25,430

35.4

Canada Thistle

17

14.3

9,108

12.7

Foxtail

10

8.4

5,740

8.0

Cocklebur

10

8.4

5,420

7.5

Redroot Pigweed

10

8.4

4,991

6.9

Kochia

7

5.9

4,990

6.9

Wild Mustard

7

5.9

4,810

6.7

Ragweed

6

5.0

1,656

2.3

Lambsquarters

3

2.5

875

1.2

Wild Oat

3

2.5

780

1.1

Volunteer Grain

1

0.8

450

0.6

Northarvest

Nightshade

51

29.0

34,554

35.7

Redroot Pigweed

18

10.2

9,420

9.7

Canada Thistle

17

9.7

9,108

9.4

Foxtail

14

8.0

7,255

7.5

Ragweed

16

9.1

5,886

6.1

Kochia

8

4.5

5,590

5.8

Cocklebur

10

5.7

5,420

5.6

Wild Mustard

9

5.1

5,271

5.4

Lambsquarters

14

8.0

4,870

5.0

Wild Oat

3

1.7

780

0.8

Volunteer Grain

1

0.6

450

0.5

aRanked as No. 1 weed problem on more than 0.5% of respondents’ areas.
bRespondents’ acres only.

 

Nightshade was ranked most frequently as one of the three worst weed problems for Northarvest respondents, with 53% of respondents' acres affected, followed by cocklebur on 31%, Canada thistle on 30%, redroot pigweed on 22%, ragweed on 22%, lambsquarters on 16% and kochia on 16% (Table 14). Nightshade was about twice as common a weed problem in 1998 as in 1997, as was cocklebur.

In Minnesota, ragweed was ranked most frequently as one of the three worst weed problems on 59% of  respondents' acres, followed by nightshade on 55%, redroot pigweed on 40%, lambsquarters on 32%, foxtail on 20%, Canada thistle on 13% and cocklebur on 11% (Table 14). Ragweed and nightshade were almost twice as commonly ranked among the three worst weeds in 1998 as in 1997. Redroot pigweed was a less commonly ranked weed problem in 1998 than in 1997.

In North Dakota, nightshade was ranked most frequently as one of the three worst weeds on 53% of respondents' acres, followed by cocklebur on 38%, Canada thistle on 37%, foxtail on 23%, kochia on 19% and redroot pigweed on 16% (Table 14). Nightshade and cocklebur were each one of the three worst weed problems on about 50% more respondents' acres in 1998 than in 1997.

Table 14: Weeds ranked one of the three worst in 1998 in Minnesota and North Dakota

 

No. 1,2 or 3
Weed Problema

Respondents <Acres Reportedb
Number % Number %
Minnesota

Ragweed

30

52.6

14,641

58.8

Nightshade

28

49.1

13,743

55.1

Redroot Pigweed 19 <33.3 9,834 39.5
Lambsquarters 22 38.6 <7,872 31.6
Foxtail 11 19.3 4,922 19.8
Canada Thistle 5 8.8 3,161 12.7
Cocklebur 10 17.5 2,704 10.9
North Dakota
Nightshade 51 42.9 37,701 52.5
Cocklebur 39 32.8 27,130 37.8
Canada Thistle 50 42.0 26,238 36.5
Foxtail 35 29.4 16,545 23.0
Kochia 23 19.3 13,550 18.9
Redroot Pigweed 23 19.3 11,796 16.4
Volunteer Grain 5 4.2 8,390 11.7
Wild Oat 15 12.6 8,233 11.5
Lambsquarters 20 16.8 7,973 11.1
Northarvest
Nightshade 79 44.9 51,544 53.2
Cocklebur 49 27.8 29,834 30.8
Canada Thistle 55 31.3 29,399 30.4
Redroot Pigweed 42 23.3 21,630 22.4
Ragweed 47 26.7 21,149 21.9
Lambsquarters 42 23.3 15,845 16.4
Kochia 27 15.3 15,380 15.9

aRanked as No. 1,2 or 3 weed problem on more than 10% of respondents’ acres.
bRespondents’ acres only.