1996 Dry Bean Grower Survey of Pest Problems and Pesticide Use in Minnesota and North Dakota 

ER 44
1998

Weed Control Practices

    The most common chemical weed control practices were post-applied bentazon (Basagran, others) and spring pre-plant incorporated Sonalan, each used on 62% of Northarvest respondents' acres (Table 27). The use of Sonalan was slightly lower than in 1995 and the use of bentazon was slightly higher. Other common chemical weed control practices included post-applied Poast on 25% of respondents' acres, post-applied Pursuit on 20%, and spring pre-plant applied trifluralin (Treflan, others) on 17%. Other chemical control practices included spring pre-plant incorporated Eptam, post-applied Assure II, and various other chemical control practices used on less than 5% of respondents' acres.

    The most common cultural weed control practice was row cultivation, used by 81% of Northarvest respondents on 79% of their acres (Table 27). Rotary hoe was used by 22% of respondents on 18% of their acres. These percentages are slightly lower than those for 1995.

    In Minnesota, post-applied bentazon was applied to 55% of respondents' acres, followed by spring pre-plant incorporated Sonalan on 52%, post-applied Poast on 29%, spring pre-plant incorporated trifluralin on 21%, spring pre-plant incorporated Eptam on 15%, pre-plant applied alachlor (Lasso, others) on 13%, and post applied Pursuit on 10% (Table 28). Use of bentazon was up from 1995, when it was applied on 45% of respondents' acres. Use of Pursuit was down from 1995, when it was applied on 17% of respondents' acres. Row cultivation was used on 85% of Minnesota respondents' acres and rotary hoe was used on 30%.

    In North Dakota, spring pre-plant incorporated Sonalan was applied to 65% of respondents' acres, followed by post-applied bentazon on 64%, post-applied Poast on 24%, post-applied Pursuit on 23%, and spring pre-plant incorporated trifluralin on 16% (Table 28). Use of Pursuit was up from 1995, when it was applied on 12% of respondents' acres. Row cultivation was used on 77% of North Dakota respondents' acres, down from 90% in 1995. Rotary hoe was used on 15% of respondents' acres, half the percentage in Minnesota.

    Post-applied bentazon (Basagran, others) was the most commonly used herbicide in MN3, MN4, MN5 and ND1, ND2 and ND5. Spring pre-plant incorporated Sonalan was the most commonly used herbicide in MN1, MN2 and ND3 (Table 29). Post-applied Pursuit was the most commonly used herbicide in ND4.

    Sodium chlorate was the most commonly used desiccant in all five Minnesota districts and ND1, ND2, ND4 and ND5 (Table 30). Grammoxone extra was the most commonly used desiccant in ND3. Desiccant use was greatest in MN4, with 39% of respondents’ acres treated, followed by MN5 with 24%, MN3 with 21%, and ND1 with 20% of respondents’ acres treated.

    Inter-row cultivation was used on the majority of respondents’ acres in all districts. Values were calculated per cultivation so acres that received more than one cultivation would have percentages over 100%. There were 102% of MN2, 99% of MN3, 91% of MN5, 87% of MN4 and ND3, 83% of ND1, 81% of MN1, 78% of ND4, 71% of ND2, and 59% of ND5 respondents’ acres cultivated (Table 31). In addition to inter-row cultivation, rotary hoe was used on 49% of MN1; 28% of ND4; 16% of ND1, ND2, and MN5; 13% of MN2; 12% of ND3; 11% of MN3; 9% of MN4, and 4% of ND5 respondents’ acres.

    A majority of respondents in all districts used two cultivations; fewer respondents used one cultivation and very few used three cultivations or more (Table 32). Four or more cultivations were used by a few respondents in MN1, MN5, ND1, ND2 and ND3.

    The rotary hoe was used once by most respondents in all districts, with 66% to 100% of respondents reporting a single use of the rotary hoe (Table 33). In ND1, ND2, and ND3 13%, 22% and 19% of respondents used two or three passes with the rotary hoe. In MN1, 34% of respondents used two, three or four passes with a rotary hoe.

 

Table 27. Weed control practicesa in 1996 by all Northarvest
respondents in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Weed Control Practice Respondents Acres Treatedb
Number % Number %
Cultivation 557 80.5 176,707 78.5
Bentazon (Basagran, others) 458 66.2 139,489 62.0
Sonalan, spring applied 445 64.3 139,412 61.9
Poast 277 40.0 57,075 25.4
Pursuit 182 26.3 44,655 19.8
Rotary hoe 149 21.5 41,258 18.3
Trifluralin, spring applied 146 21.1 37,717 16.8
Eptam, spring applied 66 9.5 15,051 6.7
Assure II 54 7.8 12,414 5.5
Roundup, preplant 87 12.6 9,753 4.3
Trifluralin, fall applied 22 3.2 8,704 3.9
Alachlor (Lasso, others) 41 5.9 8,294 3.7
Dual 34 4.9 5,838 2.6
Sonalan, fall applied 20 2.9 4,929 2.2
Prowl 39 5.6 4,789 2.1
Trifluralin + Eptam 15 2.2 3,901 1.7
Eptam, fall applied 1 0.1 1,200 0.5

aIncludes all practices or herbicides used on more than 1,000 acres.
bRespondents’ acres only.


Table 28. Common weed control practicesa in 1996 by
respondents in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Weed Control Practice Acres Treatedb
Number %
Minnesota
Cultivation 46,143 84.9
Bentazon (Basagran, others) 29,840 54.9
Sonalan, spring applied 28,354 52.2
Rotary hoe 16,198 29.8
Poast 15,694 28.9
Trifluralin, spring applied 11,289 20.8
Eptam, spring applied 8,079 14.9
Alachlor (Lasso, others) 7,181 13.2
Pursuit 5,530 10.2
North Dakota
Cultivation 130,564 76.5
Sonalan, spring applied 111,058 65.0
Bentazon (Basagran, others) 109,649 64.2
Poast 41,381 24.2
Pursuit 39,125 22.9
Trifluralin, spring applied 26,428 15.5
Rotary hoe 25,060 14.7
Northarvest
Cultivation 176,707 78.5
Bentazon (Basagran, others) 139,489 62.0
Sonalan, spring applied 139,412 61.9
Poast 57,075 25.4
Pursuit 44,655 19.8
Rotary hoe 41,258 18.3
Trifluralin, spring applied 37,717 16.8

aPractice or herbicide used on more than 10% of respondents’ acres.
bRespondents’ acres only.

 

Table 29. Herbicides commonly used in 1996 in each Northarvest
district in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Northarvest District

Herbicide Acres Reporteda
Number %
Minnesota
MN1 Sonalan, spring applied 14,381 56.4
 

 

Bentazon (Basagran, others) 12,429 48.7
Trifluralin, spring applied 5,202 20.4
MN2 Sonalan, spring applied 4,216 67.7
 

 

 

Bentazon (Basagran, others) 3,412 54.8
Alachlor (Lasso, others) 2,200 35.3
Poast 1,695 27.2
MN3 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 3,972 73.6
 

 

 

 

 

Poast 2,254 41.8
Sonalan, spring applied 2,024 37.5
Pursuit 1,407 26.1
Dual 1,350 25.0
Trifluralin, spring applied 1,131 21.0
MN4 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 2,832 46.2
 

 

 

 

Alachlor (Lasso, others) 2,117 34.5
Trifluralin, spring applied 1,974 32.2
Poast 1,544 25.2
Pursuit 1,449 23.6
MN5 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 7,195 64.7
 

 

 

Sonalan, spring applied 6,598 59.3
Trifluralin, spring applied 2,322 20.9
Eptam, spring applied 2,249 20.2
North Dakota
ND1 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 28,505 75.8
 

 

Sonalan, spring applied 24,771 65.9
Poast 17,977 47.8
ND2 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 28,616 78.7
 

 

Sonalan, spring applied 26,236 72.2
Poast 8,064 22.2
ND3 Sonalan, spring applied 34,159 74.9
 

 

Bentazon (Basagran, others) 23,722 52.0
Pursuit 15,997 35.1
ND4 Pursuit 11,685 49.2
 

 

 

Sonalan, spring applied 10,635 44.8
Bentazon (Basagran, others) 10,033 42.2
Trifluralin, spring applied 7,157 30.1
ND5 Bentazon (Basagran, others) 18,773 63.8
 

 

 

Sonalan, spring applied 15,257 51.8
Pursuit 7,451 25.3
Poast 6,209 21.1

aHerbicide use reported on more than 20% of respondents’ acres.
bDistrict respondents’ acres only.


Table 30. Desiccants used in 1996 in each Northarvest district in
Minnesota and North Dakota.

Northarvest District Dessicant Acres Reporteda
Number %
Minnesota
MN1 Sodium chlorate 2278 8.9
  Gramoxone extra 1250 4.9
MN2 Sodium chlorate 250 4.0
MN3 Sodium chlorate 319 5.9
  Gramoxone extra 834 15.5
MN4 Sodium chlorate 1672 27.3
  Gramoxone extra 712 11.6
MN5 Sodium chlorate 764 6.9
  Gramoxone extra 1893 17.0
MN Total Sodium chlorate 5283 9.7
  Gramoxone extra 4689 8.6
North Dakota
ND1 Sodium cholorate 5,831 15.5
  Gramoxone extra 1,617 4.3
ND2 Sodium chlorate 865 2.4
  Gramoxone extra 1,222 3.4
ND3 Gramoxone extra 1,100 2.5
ND4 Sodium chlorate 125 0.5
  Gramoxone extra 216 0.9
ND5 Sodium chlorate 430 1.5
  Gramoxone extra 2,263 7.7
ND Total Sodium chlorate 7,251 4.2
  Gramoxone extra 6,418 3.8
Northarvest Total Sodium chlorate 12,534 5.6
  Gramoxone extra 11,107 4.9

aDistrict respondents’ acres only.


Table 31. Use of cultivation and rotary hoe in 1996 in each
Northarvest district in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Northarvest
District
Acres Cultivated Rotary Hoe, Acres Treateda
Number % Number %
Minnesota
MN1 20,734 81.3 12,557 49.2
MN2 6,354 102.0 784 12.6
MN3 3,626 99.0 582 10.8
MN4 5,339 87.1 554 9.0
MN5 10,090 90.8 1,721 15.5
MN Total 46,143 84.9 16,198 29.8
North Dakota
ND1 31,138 82.9 6,118 16.3
ND2 25,761 70.9 5,949 16.4
ND3 37,909 87.0 5,296 12.1
ND4 18,470 77.7 6,551 27.6
ND5 17,286 58.7 1,146 3.9
North Dakota Total 130,564 76.5 25,060 14.7
Northarvest Total 176,707 78.5 41,258 18.3

aDistrict respondents’ acres only.


Table 32. Number of cultivations of dry beans in 1996 in each
Northarvest district in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Northarvest District

Number of Cultivations

1

2

3

4

5

>5

% of Respondentsa

Minnesota
MN1 18.2 69.1 9.1 3.6 0 0
MN2 31.3 56.3 12.5 0 0 0
MN3 24.1 72.4 3.4 0 0 0
MN4 29.3 65.9 4.9 0 0 0
MN5 36.8 57.9 2.6 2.6 0 0
MN Total 26.8 65.4 6.1 1.7 0 0
North Dakota
ND1 10.8 69.6 17.6 1.0 0 1.0
ND2 18.2 65.2 15.2 1.5 0 0
ND3 34.3 59.6 5.1 0 1.0 0
ND4 19.2 75.0 5.8 0 0 0
ND5 42.4 52.5 5.1 0 0 0
ND Total 24.3 64.3 10.3 0.5 0.3 0.3

a% of respondents answering question.


Table 33. Number of times rotary hoe was used on dry beans in
1996 in each Northarvest district in Minnesota and North Dakota.

Northarvest District

Number of Times Rotary Hoe Useda

1 2 3 4
Minnesota
MN1 65.5 20.7 10.3 3.4
MN2 100.0 0 0 0
MN3 100.0 0 0 0
MN4 100.0 0 0 0
MN5 87.5 12.5 0 0
MN Total 79.2 13.2 5.7 1.9
North Dakota
ND1 87.0 8.7 4.3 0
ND2 78.3 17.4 4.3 0
ND3 81.0 14.3 4.8 0
ND4 90.5 9.5 0 0
ND5 100.0 0 0 0
ND Total 85.4 11.5 3.1 0

a% of respondents answering question.


This site was last updated on November 14, 2002

 

202 Hultz Hall
Department of Entomology
College of Agriculture
Fargo, North Dakota 58105-5346
Phone: (701) 231-7581
FAX: (701) 231-8557

For more information, please contact:

Extension Entomologist: Phillip Glogoza   pglogoza@ndsuext.nodak.edu